Milo Ventimiglia’s performance as Tim Timmons stands out in the film. He is described as the story’s grounding force and its most magnetic presence. Based on a screenplay by McCorkle His portrayal brings steady emotion and energy, making it one of the movie’s most engaging highlights
Directed by Andrew Erwin and Brent McCorkle, I Can Only Imagine 2 is a biographical Christian drama film released in theaters today, February 20, 2026. Its sequel to I Can Only Imagine (2018).
The film carries forward the true story of MercyMe frontman Bart Millard and explores the inspiration for the hit single “Even If.” The film picks up after the band’s meteoric rise, centering on Bart as he struggles with the demands of fame while confronting a deeply personal challenge: his young son Sam’s diagnosis with Type 1 diabetes.
The debut film, I Can Only Imagine, born from the song itself, unfolds against the backdrop of Bart’s turbulent upbringing in Texas, marked by the difficult relationship with his father, Arthur. (portrayed by Dennis Quaid). At its heart, the narrative is about redemption—how father and son eventually found reconciliation, and how Arthur’s transformation through faith became the spark that shaped the lyrics of one of the most beloved songs.
Milo Ventimiglia played the character of singer-songwriter Tim Timmons. American singer Timothy Timmons (born February 9, 1976, age 50) is known for contemporary worship and Christian music. Cast My Cares, His debut album, was released in 2013 and produced by Paul Mabury.
The album’s main track, released on March 22, 2013, reached No. 21 on the Christian Songs chart. He later released more albums, including Awake Our Souls in 2015, Who I Am in 2017, and HERE in 2021 through Integrity Music.
Several of his singles also performed well on Christian charts. “Starts With Me” hit No. 21 in 2013. “Awake Our Souls” reached No. 33 on Christian Airplay. “Everywhere I Go” peaked at No. 36 in 2016. “I Belong,” featuring Amy Grant, reached No. 39 in 2018. “You Never Let Go,” featuring Tammi Haddon, also gained airplay in 2020.
Married to Hilary Beth Timmons, he is the father of four—Malia, Noah, and twins Aaron and Anna. In June 2001, doctors diagnosed him with cancer and told him he might have only five years to live. The news changed his life. It made his faith stronger and inspired his music, which often speaks about hope, trust, and staying strong during difficult times.
The sequel also stars John Michael Finley, who returns to reprise his role as Bart Millard, Sophie Skelton portrays Bart’s wife, Shannon, and Sammy Dell steps in as Bart’s son, Sam. The ensemble is rounded out by familiar faces, with Dennis Quaid and Trace Adkins also reprising their roles, bringing both continuity and depth to the story with Arielle Kebbel as Hilary Timmons.
I Can Only Imagine 2 vs. Part 1: Cast Comparison
The main cast from the first film returns to keep the story consistent. Bart Millard is again played by John Michael Finley. Dennis Quaid returns as Arthur Millard, Bart’s father, appearing through emotional flashback scenes. Trace Adkins is back as manager Scott Brickell, and Jason Burkey reprises his role as guitarist Mike Scheuchzer. Together, they help continue the journey of Bart and the band MercyMe.
The sequel also adds new faces and one recast role. Shannon Millard is now played by Sophie Skelton, replacing Madeline Carroll. Milo Ventimiglia joins as singer Tim Timmons, who becomes a mentor to Bart. Sammy Dell plays Bart’s son Sam, whose health crisis drives the story. Arielle Kebbel appears as Hilary Timmons, while Joshua Bassett plays Christopher, Bart’s brother-in-law.
Predicted Streaming Timeline
The film should be available to buy or rent on digital platforms like Amazon Prime Video, Apple TV, and Fandango at Home about 45 to 60 days after its theatrical release, which means sometime in mid to late April 2026. After that, it’s expected to stream on Amazon Prime Video or Starz around four months after hitting theaters, likely by mid to late June 2026.
You’d like to revisit the debut movie I Can Only Imagine (2018) before the sequel; you won’t have to look far. The film is streaming free on BYUtv, and it’s also available to subscribers on Hulu and Netflix. Easy access makes it simple to relive Bart Millard’s story before stepping into the next chapter.
